Teaching kids generosity can be challenging when holiday wish lists take center stage.
A 7-year-old tears through the last gift in the pile, tosses the paper aside and asks in a whiny voice, “Is that all?”
Ten minutes of unwrapping, and she’s already asking for more.
Many parents who have hosted a gift-giving morning have watched this play out. It isn’t a character flaw on the children’s part. It’s what happens when “getting” becomes the whole point of the holidays. Kids absorb the message that receiving gifts is the main event. Gratitude, family time and whatever the holiday itself actually honors can end up as an afterthought.
Key Takeaways
We love them, so we spoil them
It’s natural to want to spoil the people we love most. Gifts are an easy, visible way to express love. But the most generous thing we can give a child may be the opposite: teaching them that giving feels better than receiving. That’s a hard lesson to teach amid wish lists and countdown calendars.
There’s another less noble reason gifts pile up. A meltdown at the checkout line. A restaurant argument that won’t end. A work call that can’t be interrupted. Buying something is often the fastest way to make the noise stop. But as psychologist Laura Markham points out, a child who needs a toy to cooperate is often signaling something else: a need for connection. The gift becomes a stand-in for time and attention we couldn’t offer just then.
Why giving more isn’t more
Researchers who study childhood overindulgence, published through the National Council on Family Relations, have tracked what happens to kids raised in excess over decades. The pattern holds: overindulged kids often grow into adults with a strong sense of entitlement and less capacity for responsibility. They can also struggle to handle disappointment, since so few of their wants ever went unmet.
Think of it like sugar. An occasional treat is harmless. A diet of nothing else makes anyone sick. Gifts work the same way. A 2025 study in Frontiers in Child and Adolescent Psychiatry found that parents’ own materialistic values predicted weaker family relationships and higher psychological distress in their kids. Wanting more rarely satisfies for long.
The case for contribution
Flip the direction of the gift, and the effect changes completely. According to KidsHealth, from the Nemours Foundation, helping others builds real empathy in children and shows them they can make a difference, not just enjoy one.
Harvard’s Making Caring Common project has spent over a decade studying exactly this question, and their findings are consistent: kids who practice generosity and gratitude regularly grow into more resilient, connected adults. The Kids Mental Health Foundation adds that small acts of kindness release real feel-good chemicals in a child’s brain the same ones adults get from generosity.
So what does that kind of giving actually look like at home? A few places to start:
Make something
A handmade gift carries something store-bought ones can’t. PBS KIDS for Parents keeps a running list of simple craft projects by age, from painted frames to homemade ornaments. The extra effort it takes is the point, not a drawback.
The time trade
Kids spell love “T-I-M-E.” They crave time from us more than they crave things from us. That’s exactly why a coupon book made by a child, for a parent or grandparent works so well. It’s filled with small promises: a game of catch, help with a chore, extra hugs on demand. Call it the world’s cutest loophole. By giving us a coupon for their time, kids guarantee they’ll get ours. And in the process, they’ve practiced the very lesson this article is about: giving beats getting.
Practice small kindnesses
Shoveling a neighbor’s walk. Holding a door for someone with full hands. A genuine smile at a new kid at school. None of these cost us or them money. Each lets a child feel, firsthand, how good it feels to give rather than receive.
Confident parenting, one email at a time.
Get expert-backed parenting advice, age-by-age tips, and health and wellness guidance for raising kids across D.C., Maryland and Northern Virginia — delivered straight to your inbox.
Make giving a family habit
Kids learn generosity by watching adults practice it, not by hearing a lecture about it. A few places to start:
- Ask your child who they’d like to make something for.
- Let your child choose one toy to give away before new ones arrive.
- Turn one family holiday errand into a chance to help someone else.
None of this requires a big production. Small, repeated moments teach the lesson better than any lecture could.
Picture that same 7-year-old a few years from now, wrapping something she made herself for a grandparent, asking not “is that all?” but “who else can I make something for?” That’s the shift worth aiming for right now: not fewer gifts, but a different direction for them.
Frequently Asked Questions
How can I teach my child to appreciate gifts?
Help your child notice the thought behind a gift and thank the person who gave it. Practice gratitude year-round for everyday kindnesses and time together, too.
Does giving my child lots of gifts mean I’m spoiling them?
The number of gifts alone doesn’t tell the whole story. Notice whether presents are replacing connection, becoming rewards for cooperation or making it harder for your child to accept limits.
What are simple ways children can give without spending money?
Children can make a card, help with a chore or create a coupon for time together. Welcoming a new classmate or helping a neighbor also gives them a chance to contribute.
How can we make generosity a family habit?
Build small acts of giving into everyday life, and let your child help choose them. Making gifts, helping neighbors and giving back together show children what generosity looks like in practice.
Why is teaching kids generosity so important?
Teaching kids generosity helps children understand others’ needs and make a difference. Practicing generosity through sharing, helping and giving encourages empathy, gratitude and stronger connections.
Read Next
Ready to put generosity into practice? Explore 5 Ways to Give Back as a Family for ideas you can try together.







